Don’t let this entry fool you but I’ve had 90 per cent good teaching days but one lesson today totally sucked. I pride myself in always making my lessons fun and interesting. In fact I get annoyed when people say, “Isn’t teaching frustrating? I don’t know how you do it!” I mean, are venture capitalists given such sniffy comments?
Most of my students are fairly chatty as they are genuinely keen on expressing themselves in English. This group also loves the language so it pleases me that they go to lengths to speak their minds or mention something unusual. The others whom I classify as raw beginners show more or less the same enthusiasm.
But I have one particular student, Makiko, who is difficult. She takes conversational lessons to communicate with her French boss in English. She doesn’t say this frankly but I gathered from our numerous lessons that this boss of hers is a difficult man to deal with. I imagine French impatience and arrogance, plus an equal inability to communicate well in English, on top of an unwillingness to learn any Japanese are a recipe for disaster.
After two months, I had a particularly trying lesson with her. She clammed up at whatever I suggested. I was worried that she couldn’t understand me at all and asked her many questions to promote conversation but she froze. Then she burst out with a breaking voice, “It’s too difficult for me! Why can’t I speak spontaneously after two months’ of lessons?” She also added with her lower lip trembling, “I need more time to read and understand the article. I can’t just read it once.”
I was quite shocked because a) how could you expect dramatic results after eight weeks? b) why didn’t she tell me earlier it was too difficult? c) I’ve never made anyone cry during a lesson. I always knew that the average Japanese is rather reserved, and so, less talkative or expressive. I’ve also learned that being indirect is one of the hallmarks of the Japanese “way”. Sometimes I take refuge in that because I’m not fond of confrontations myself but I do feel this overwhelming suffocation when I’m faced with this wall of silent opaqueness.
So we reformulated her class — I would give her the news articles beforehand so she could have a thorough read and to check out all the words she didn’t know. This would give her more time to talk during the lesson. I had misgivings about this because her problem is not really a lack of English grammar or vocabulary but really about self-confidence. It seems she hates looking like she doesn’t know what she is looking at or to be unprepared. But how do I foster “spontaneity” if she clearly abhors being put on the spot? The crux of having conversational lessons is to be in an environment where you are more or less unprepared so you can speak on the fly.
When I send the articles to her a week before our next lesson I would gently remind her to think of related topics to talk about, but without fail, when I meet her, she would fidget awkwardly and I would launch into various topics first. Most days I’m fine with this as I feel it’s my responsibility to take the initiative but today I felt a wave of irritation when she didn’t complete her sentences and looked absolutely lost. I tried to guess what she was trying to say, encouraged her to use her dictionary and told her to forget about grammar for once. Usually I would overlook her silence, let her dismiss her half-formed thought and move on to the next topic but I just had about enough of her meekness today.
She looked like she was going to cry. Instead of feeling sympathy, I was even more annoyed as I thought inwardly, “You’re 40! You work for a huge multinational nuclear energy company! Who on earth is going to keep being so patient with your shyness or unwillingness to speak up?!” Mind you, I didn’t scold her at all. Maybe my forced smile was enough to fling her into a spiral of fear.
I skipped to the next topic where she clammed up again so I was thankful when the clock said it was the end of our hour. Here I am, surfing around the Internet, looking for other teachers in Japan with the same problem and perhaps offer me a solution to this dreadful pain of a silent student. It seems this behaviour is quite common and it must be worse if you’re facing 25 poker faces — so I’m in a luckier position apparently. I hope next Wednesday wouldn’t have a repeat of this. Boiling away now…